Make A Booking Call Now

Tax Fraud in Victoria: Charges, Penalties and Defences

Transcript

If the ATO has referred your matter to the CDPP, you are no longer in a tax dispute. You are in a criminal case.

What the charge actually means. Tax fraud covers a range of Commonwealth charges. The common thread is that money the Commonwealth was entitled to did not come in, or money went out that should not have, and the prosecution says you knew. That might be false returns, invented deductions, or GST refunds claimed on invoices for work that never happened.

What the prosecution has to prove. The prosecution has to prove a dishonest state of mind. Being wrong is not enough. Relying on an accountant is not enough. The prosecutors have to satisfy a jury that you knew the position you took was false, and you took it anyway. That is a much higher bar than the ATO needs for, say, a penalty assessment.

What matters in defending these charges? The early work you do on a file matters more than the trial. Who prepared the returns? What advice were you given? What were you told to do? Whether the auditor has read the ledgers correctly? We have run many of these matters where the quantum was enormous and dropped dramatically once the accounting was properly examined.

If you have had a notice, an audit, or a knock on the door, get advice before you answer anything. Doogue + George have run some of the largest tax frauds in the country. If police have contacted you, speak to us before you speak to them.

Understanding Tax Fraud Charges in Victoria

If you are under investigation for tax fraud, you need to know which laws apply. Most tax fraud prosecuted in Victoria involves Commonwealth revenue, not state tax. This video explains what the charge means, what the prosecution must prove, and when to engage experienced tax fraud lawyers in Melbourne.

How Tax Fraud Is Prosecuted in Australia

Tax fraud sits across two legal systems. Commonwealth taxes, including income tax, GST and PAYG withholding, are investigated by the ATO and prosecuted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP), sometimes with the Australian Federal Police (AFP). State taxes fall to the State Revenue Office (SRO). Whether the matter is a state or Commonwealth charge decides which court and penalties apply.

Tax Fraud Offences and Penalties

Most serious tax fraud is charged under the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth): obtaining property by deception (section 134.1), obtaining a financial advantage by deception (section 134.2), and conspiracy to defraud (section 135.4), each carrying up to 10 years’ imprisonment. A lesser charge under section 135.2 carries up to 12 months. At state level, serious deception is prosecuted under section 82 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), also up to 10 years.

What Must the Prosecution Prove?

The central issue is dishonesty. The prosecution must prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that you acted with a dishonest state of mind. An honest mistake, careless bookkeeping, or a position taken on your accountant’s advice is not a crime. They must satisfy a jury that you knew the return was false and lodged it anyway.

How Tax Fraud Charges Are Defended

The strongest work happens early, well before trial. Who prepared the returns, what advice you were given, and whether the auditor read the ledgers correctly all matter. The alleged quantum is often overstated and can fall substantially once the accounting is examined properly. Challenging the forensic accounting is central to how criminal lawyers for tax fraud defend these matters.

What to Do If the ATO or AFP Contacts You

A notice, an audit, or officers at your door are not the moment to explain yourself. Anything you say can end up in the brief of evidence. A voluntary disclosure before an investigation begins can sometimes reduce penalties, but make that decision with a lawyer, not alone.

Why Early Legal Advice Matters

Tax fraud matters are document-heavy, and the first few weeks shape everything that follows. Early advice lets an experienced tax fraud defence lawyer assess the evidence, protect you in any interview, and deal with the ATO, AFP or CDPP on your behalf. If you have been contacted, call (03) 9670 5111 before you respond.

FAQs

Is tax fraud a state or Commonwealth offence in Victoria?

Usually Commonwealth. Most matters involve income tax, GST or PAYG under the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth). State taxes are handled by the SRO.
The main Commonwealth charges carry up to 10 years' imprisonment, depending on the amount involved and your role.
Not on that basis alone. The prosecution must prove you were dishonest under the same fraud and deception principles used across Victorian law.
No. Get legal advice before answering questions or handing over documents, because anything you say may be used against you.
Yes. The quantum is frequently reduced once the accounting is examined properly.