Make A Booking Call Now

The Law on Blackmail and Menaces in Victoria

Transcript

Blackmail is not always a threat of violence. Quite often, it starts as a demand that somebody pay what they owe.

What the charge of blackmail actually means. The offence is making an unwarranted demand with menaces, with a view to gain or to cause loss. Menaces, as a concept, is broader than most people expect. It includes threatening to expose someone, to go to the police, to tell an employer, or to release information. The demand does not have to succeed. Making it is enough.

What the prosecution has to prove. The prosecution must show the demand was unwarranted and that it was backed by menaces. The law recognises that some demands are proper. If you honestly believed you had reasonable grounds for the demand, and you honestly believed the menace was a proper way of reinforcing it, that could possibly be a defence.

What matters in defending charges such as these. These cases very often come out of a genuine dispute, a debt, a business breakup, a relationship breakup. The person making the demand thought they were entitled to something. That belief is legally relevant, and it needs to be documented properly and early. We also look at how the conversation was recorded and whether the words used actually carry the meaning the prosecution puts on them.

A blackmail charge is serious, and it often carries a real risk of going to jail. If you have been charged or interviewed, contact Doogue + George. If police have contacted you, speak to us before you speak to them.

Blackmail Is Not Always About Violence

Under section 87 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), blackmail is a serious indictable offence, and the conduct it captures is wider than most people assume. It does not require a threat of violence, and often begins as a demand that someone pay what they owe. If you are looking for blackmail lawyers in Melbourne, the first step is understanding what the prosecution has to prove.

When a Demand Crosses Into Blackmail

Blackmail is making an unwarranted demand with menaces, with a view to gain for yourself or another, or to cause a loss. The nature of what you demand does not matter. What matters is that the demand is unwarranted and backed by menaces. Importantly, the demand does not have to succeed. The offence is complete the moment the demand is made, even if no money ever changes hands.

What Counts as a Menace?

A menace is far broader than a threat of violence. It includes threatening to expose private information, to go to the police, to tell an employer, or to release damaging material. Threatening to reveal something true can still be a menace. Online threats and harassment, including sextortion, are regularly charged under the same section.

When Your Belief Is a Defence

The law accepts that some demands are proper. A demand with menaces is not unwarranted if you genuinely believed two things: that you had reasonable grounds for making the demand, and that the menace was a proper means of reinforcing it. This is why your state of mind matters. An honest belief in your entitlement can be central to a blackmail defence lawyer’s case.

Genuine Disputes and What Was Actually Said

These charges very often come out of a genuine dispute, a debt, a business breakup or a relationship breakup, where the person believed they were entitled to something. That belief needs to be documented properly and early. Criminal lawyers for blackmail also examine how the conversation was recorded, and whether the words used actually carry the meaning the prosecution places on them.

Penalties and the Real Risk of Prison

Blackmail carries a maximum penalty of 15 years’ imprisonment, and a conviction often brings a real risk of a custodial sentence. As a serious indictable offence, it usually proceeds through a committal in the County Court. Outcomes range from imprisonment to a Community Correction Order, depending on the circumstances. If police have contacted you, call (03) 9670 5111 before you speak to them.

FAQs

Does blackmail have to involve violence?

No. A menace can be a threat to expose information, go to the police or tell an employer, not just a threat of violence.
Yes. The offence is complete once the unwarranted demand with menaces is made, whether or not it succeeds.
It can be. Threatening to reveal true information can still be a menace where the demand is unwarranted.
That may be a defence if you honestly believed you had reasonable grounds and that the menace was a proper way to reinforce the demand.
Fifteen years' imprisonment. It is a serious indictable offence and a custodial sentence is a real possibility.
Yes. Threatening to release intimate images to extract money or a benefit is prosecuted as blackmail or related cyber offences.