Make A Booking Call Now

Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth)

Table of Contents

Maya George

Author: Maya George

Practice area: Centrelink

Maya is an Associate at Doogue + George with experience in terrorism and serious federal criminal matters. Her depth of experience in this area means clients receive accurate, considered advice.

View full profile →

Maya authored this content and last revised it for accuracy on 7 September 2026.

What is the offence of Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth)?

Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth) is a serious fraud offence under section 134.2 of the Criminal Code Act 1995. It applies to dishonest conduct involving Commonwealth government payments or financial benefits, including allegations connected to Centrelink and taxation matters.

Key points

  • Legal elements: Dishonesty, deception, and obtaining a financial advantage from a Commonwealth entity.
  • Type of conduct: False or misleading information used to receive government payments or financial benefits.
  • Court jurisdiction: Magistrates’ Court if under $100,000; County Court if over $100,000.

The maximum penalty for Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth) is 10 years imprisonment.

Common defences may include factual dispute; lack of dishonest intent; no financial advantage obtained; duress; honest and reasonable mistake of fact.

Note that this offence is different from section 135.2 wherein the person knew that they were not entitled to the financial advantage.

Have you been accused of Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth)? Cases concerning charges of this kind can often be complicated and involve a large volume of material. It is important you contact our office as soon as you receive any information about accusations of this kind.

Obtain Financial Advantage by deception - Centrelink

Police Interview

Before speaking with the Police or offering any information, we recommend you contact our office to discuss the purpose and procedure of Police interviews. It is crucial you understand your rights.

Police want to conduct an interview with you because they suspect you have committed the offence of obtaining a financial advantage by deception and hope you will make admissions which will assist in an investigation or prosecution of the charge against you. A Police interview is not the time or place where you explain your side of the story in the hope the allegations will not progress to formal charges.

Our lawyers regularly attend Police interviews. It is our experience that people feel more comfortable attending with someone to represent their interests, and to ensure Police conduct the process in a proper and appropriate way.

Legislation

The legislation for this offence can be found on section 134.2 of  Criminal Code Act 1995.

What is the Legal Definition of Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth)?

A person commits this offence if he/she dishonestly obtains property belonging to a Commonwealth entity dishonestly with an intention of permanently deprive.

Definition of ‘Obtained’

Under the Commonwealth Criminal Code, a person is taken to have obtained property if:

  • the person obtains ownership, possession or control of the property for himself or herself or for another person; or
  • the first person enables ownership, possession or control of it to be retained by himself or herself; or
  • the person induces a third person to pass ownership, possession or control of it to another person. For example, convincing someone to receive a transfer of Commonwealth money and to then forward on to another person; or
  • the person induces a second person to enable a third person to retain ownership, possession or control of the property. For example, person A leads Person B to believe that fraudulently obtained Commonwealth money belongs to Person C.

Definition of ‘Permanently Deprive’

The Commonwealth Criminal Code defines to ‘permanently deprive’ as:

  • a person permanently obtains funds belonging to a Commonwealth entity without intending to return it; or
  • a person obtains funds belonging to a Commonwealth entity without intending to permanently keep it, but he/she disposes of it and treats it as if it is their own.

Elements of the Offence

For this charge to be proven, the Prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt that:

  • the accused dishonestly obtains a financial advantage from another person by deceiving that person; and
  • the other person is a Commonwealth entity

Examples of Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth):

The most common examples of Obtaining a financial advantage by deception relate to tax fraud and Centrelink fraud.

  • Tax Fraud:
    • Where a person or company has provided false information to the ATO and received a greater tax refund than they were entitled to.
  • Centrelink Fraud:
    • Lying about your employment status on a Centrelink form to receive a pension
    • Lying about your relationship status on a Centrelink form to receive a higher allowance

Pre-Charge Investigation

As criminal defence lawyers, our first aim is to see if there is a way to stop a case before a person is charged by the police or Agency. Once you have been interviewed or become aware that you are being investigated, advice should be obtained to see if it can be stopped before it progresses to charges. More information relating to pre-charge work can found by following this link.

Pleading Guilty

If you choose to plead guilty to this charge, our lawyers will assist you in achieving the most favourable outcome possible. We will carefully review the brief of evidence and, where appropriate, negotiate the charges or the agreed facts to ensure they accurately reflect what occurred. Our team will gather all relevant materials—such as character references and expert reports—to persuade the court to impose a sentence that is just, fair, and appropriate. Throughout the process, we ensure you are fully informed and supported at every stage until the best possible sentence is achieved.

Sentencing

The penalty that will be imposed in breaches of this section will vary significantly depending on the gravity of the offence. Factors relevant to the assessment of the gravity of the offending include the monetary value of the deception, the level of sophistication, the period of time over which the offending takes place and the role of the person who committed the offence. If the monetary value is over $100,000 it will be determined in the County Court. If the value is less, it will be determined in the Magistrates Court.

The penalty in your case will depend on the seriousness of the offending, the context to the offending, the quality of the material available to put in mitigation and the skill of the lawyer representing you.

Sentencing in the Higher Courts of Victoria

Higher courts sentencing pie chart

Source: Sentencing Advisory Council of Victoria (SACStat), Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 134.2(1) — 105 charges across 41 cases, higher courts, 1 July 2019 – 30 June 2024.

Outcome%
Imprisonment94.3%
Community Correction Order2.9%
Bond without conviction2.9%

The data indicates that a custodial sentence is highly likely at this level, reflecting the seriousness of large-scale or aggravated fraud against government entities. Non-custodial outcomes are rare. In determining penalty, the court will consider factors such as the amount involved, the level of planning, prior history and any steps taken toward restitution. Experienced legal representation is critical where imprisonment is strongly in prospect.

Sentencing in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria

Magistrates court sentencing pie chart

Source: Sentencing Advisory Council of Victoria (SACStat), Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 134.2(1) — 294 charges across 121 cases, Magistrates’ Court, 1 July 2018 – 30 June 2023.

Outcome%
Community Correction Order37.1%
Imprisonment28.9%
Fine with conviction17.0%
Bond with conviction8.2%
Bond without conviction7.8%
Diversion program1.0%

These figures demonstrate that custody is a real risk, although courts frequently impose community-based supervision or bond-type outcomes. The sentence will depend on the value involved, the level of dishonesty and the offender’s personal circumstances. Early legal advice can significantly influence the final result.

Pleading Not Guilty

We have vast experience in representing people charged with obtaining a financial advantage by deception (Commonwealth). We have run and won many jury trials and contested hearings. We are able to navigate the sophisticated and voluminous briefs of evidence that often accompany charges of this kind, and closely analyse the case that has been brought against you. We will work hard to defend you of this charge.

Can the Prosecution prove that you obtained a financial advantage?

Defences

There are a range of defences available if you are charged with this offence:

  • Factual dispute
  • Lack of intent to act dishonestly
  • No financial advantage was gained
  • Duress
  • Honest and reasonable mistake of belief as to fact

Deciding on whether to plead guilty or not has important implications for you and should be made after proper discussions with our criminal lawyers.

Questions in Cases Like This

  • Did you intentionally provide misleading information?
  • Was the conduct dishonest, or honest and reasonable?
  • Were you mistaken when you completed the Centrelink form?
  • Have your circumstances changed since you provided the information?
  • Did you receive a financial benefit that you were not entitled to?

Maximum Penalty for Section 134.2 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code

There is a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment for anyone found guilty of obtaining financial advantage by deception (s134.2 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code).

You should call our office on 9670 5111 to discuss your matter with one of our expert lawyers.

Case studies related to Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth – Centrelink Charge

FAQ about Obtain a Financial Advantage By Deception (Commonwealth)

What must police prove to convict for obtaining a financial advantage by deception?
The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused dishonestly obtained a financial advantage, that the advantage was obtained by deception, and that the person or body deceived was a Commonwealth entity.
Yes. Providing false information to Centrelink, such as misrepresenting employment or relationship status to receive payments, can amount to this offence where the conduct involves dishonest deception to obtain a financial benefit.
Yes. Supplying false information to the Australian Taxation Office and receiving a greater tax refund than properly payable can constitute obtaining a financial advantage by deception if the conduct is dishonest and directed at a Commonwealth entity.
Section 134.2 requires proof that a financial advantage was obtained by deception. Section 135.2 instead applies where a person obtains a financial advantage from a Commonwealth entity knowing they are not entitled to it, without the same requirement to prove deceptive conduct.
Issues often include whether the information provided was intentionally misleading, whether the conduct was dishonest, whether a financial advantage was actually obtained, and whether the accused acted under an honest and reasonable mistake of fact or under duress.