Attending Police Stations

Attending a police station to be interviewed by the police can be a very stressful experience.

This section of the website has been designed to inform you of your rights and answer questions like:

Doogue O’Brien George has a team of criminal lawyers who are highly experienced in dealing with the Police.
If you are at all concerned about your interview with the police, call us on 03 9670 5111.

There are a number of guidelines that we recommend you read before attending a police station – please see below:

DO

  • Ask why you are being arrested
  • Give your name and address
  • Ask the police for a telephone so you can contact Doogue O’Brien George
    (it is not an automatic right, but you can request the use of a telephone)
  • Ask for bail
  • Be polite
  • Dress well for the interview as it will be recorded on video

DON’T

  • Answer any questions except to give your name and address
    (if you are the owner of a car or trailer you must give information which would lead to the driver if you are asked)
  • Make any statements in writing
  • Make any statements in words
  • Sign anything
  • Plead guilty to anything unless you have spoken to a solicitor
    (even if they tell you to)
  • Resist arrest
  • Be abusive or impolite

* If you are under 18 years of age you must have an adult you trust present.

What is the purpose of a Police Interview?

The aim of a Police interview is to obtain admissible evidence with which to prosecute you.
It is not a search for the truth. The Police are not generally trying to get your version of events so they can compare it to another version of what happened. If it was a search for the truth they would not be videotaping your interview.

People who have never been in trouble before tend to misunderstand a Police interview.

They believe that going in there and telling the truth as they remember it will fix the matter. Unfortunately that is not true. The Police will often know that you are going to deny the charges before they interview you. The reason they are interviewing you is to tie you into a position. They are often trying to get you to commit to something that is wrong so they can later claim that you are a liar. (for example “who was there?” – if you leave someone out they would prove they were there and use that fact against you).

You should also remember that the Police are experienced questioners. They regularly cross-examine and question people in police interviews.

Why does a Police interview happen?

A Police interview happens because they have identified you as a suspect. A person who is not a suspect might be invited in to the Police Station to make a statement. The difference between the two is that you must to attend an interview but you do not have to agree to make a statement.

How do Police Interviews happen?

The Police will either arrest you and take you to the Police Station or arrange an interview by appointment. If the offence is not a minor one, the Police do have the power to arrest you to take you to an interview. This can be very embarrassing if you are arrested at your workplace or home and is a good reason why you should make an appointment if asked, rather than avoid the issue. In the event you are given the option of an appointment, the Police will call you and arrange a time to attend the Police Station to be interviewed.

It is imperative that you comply with your agreed appointment time. It is common sense that this not the time to put off your interview or otherwise inconveniencing the Police.

If the charges are at all serious, you should be scheduling the interview for as early in the day as possible and avoid Fridays. The reason for this is that if the Police have interviewed you and refused bail at the end, if it is early enough, you can get before a Court and may be granted bail. If you are interviewed on a Friday and the Police refuse bail you may have to stay there all weekend.

How does a Police interview start?

An interview starts with the Police asking you questions about whether you understand your rights.
They will ask you if you want to contact a lawyer and if you do not know one they will give you a yellow pages to look through (which is generally unhelpful). So, make sure you have your criminal lawyer’s number in your pocket.

It is always wise to discuss the interview with your lawyer prior to attending, because the decision about whether to talk or do a “no comment” interview is a very important one with lots of considerations.

Often, it pays to ring your lawyer when the Police gives you the option to as your lawyer can have a discussion with the Police. This is often useful in getting a gauge of what charges might be pending and whether you will be bailed. If they are not going to bail you, then it helps to arrange to have a lawyer at Court to arrange the bail application.

What happens during the Police interview?

The Police will ask you a series of questions about what happened. Usually, once you have given your version, they will put the other version of events to you and ask you to comment. This is where interviews often go wrong as the interviewee is annoyed and says things that they later come to regret.

Who will be in the Police interview?

The informant (the police officer who will charge you) and a corroborator (another Police Officer who is a witness to what happened). You will be there of course and your lawyer, if you take one with you.

Do I need a lawyer with me in a Police interview?

Like many things it depends on the circumstances. If you are attending an interview on a fairly straight forward matter and doing a “no comment” interview, then it is a purely economic decision and your choice. We would not advise you to take a lawyer to something like that as it would be a waste of money.

Can I have a family member in the interview?

If you are not a child, the Police do not have to let anyone else into the interview (other than your lawyer).
We advise that have some of your family members (if they are in no way involved) to go with you to the Police Station and wait for you to be interviewed.

What is a “no comment” interview?

A “no comment” interview is one in which the accused tells their name and address details and then says “no comment” to every question after that.

It is very important that if you do a “no comment” interview that you say “no comment” to every question. You can not answer some questions and say “no comment” to others. The reason for this is that a partial “no comment” interview can be used against you.

Why would I do a “no comment” interview?

You would do a “no comment” interview because you do not want the Police to use your own words against you. The right against self-incrimination is one of the most fundamental rights we have. The Police have enormous resources and enormous powers and if they can prove you did something, then the burden of proof lies with them. However, a citizen should not be forced to get themselves in trouble or trip themselves up by answering questions. Often, simply erring by giving an incorrect date, having a speech impediment or sounding untrustworthy (when they are not) is enough for the Police to use against someone in Court.

What is the consequence of a “no comment” interview?

The fact there has been a “no comment” interview can not be lead as evidence. It does not imply guilt and is generally completely neutral.

Can I give a statement at a later time?

Once you have been interviewed, you and your lawyer may provide the Police with a statement of what you say happened. It would be rare to do that, but it happens occasionally.

How long does the Police interview go for?

An interview can go for a number of hours. If it is a “no comment” interview it will be much shorter and is often over within 10 – 20 minutes. The Police will often leave you waiting for a long time prior to interviewing you. This is just a standard technique to try to make you more stressed. It is our advice that you take a good book with you so that you can spend the time productively.

How do they record interviews?

An interview is recorded on DVD. So, it is wise to do obvious things such as shave and dress appropriately prior to being interviewed. The interview is an important step in the process and one that might be viewed by a number of people.

Advice on behaviour at the Police Station

It should go without saying that your behaviour is polite and respectful towards the Police when being interviewed. Mostly, they are just doing their job and will respond in kind to people who are rude to them.

What should I do if the Police say they will not give me bail unless I plead guilty to the offence?

Think about their motivation. They obviously need you to give a statement to make the case against you stronger. You might get some short term benefit but in the long term it will hurt you. Do not plead guilty to things you have not done. Make sure that you confirm what they said on the recorded interview. ie say – I am only pleading guilty because you said I would not get bail otherwise. You can then bet they will deny saying it to you as they are not allowed to pressure you in that way to get a statement from you.

Should I sign any documents in the interview?

Sign nothing and mark nothing if you are doing a “no comment” interview.

What happens after the interview?

You will be fingerprinted and possibly be asked whether you will supply DNA. They will then take you to the watchhouse if you are being bailed and a different officer will ask you some questions about whether you have a complaint to make. They will then release you.

You should then ring your lawyer and go and have a discussion with them about what is going on.

There are often a lot of important issues to deal with straight away.